Piano instructional software with real-time feedback?
What are some software programs that grant a digital piano learner real time feedback via usb or midi or other interfaces? In the 90s I bought a guitar fret that would interface with a pc (good concept but garbage hardware), is there something similar for piano?
I think that instructional software that interfaces with a digital piano via MIDI would be superior to a warm body instructor as the lesson is consistently available and a one-time fee.
Look at SmartMusic. There are modes in this excellent software that will assess your performance for ACCURACY by cmparing it to a silent track. You get a printout, if you wish, that shows your deviation from perfect accuracy. Of course, this does not assess things that are subjective - only objective - but it's a start.
NOTHING is superior to a live teacher - NOTHING. I have worked extensively with many, many music software programs, and hold multiple degrees in music education and music theory. I wrote my MM thesis at Boston University about CAI - computer -assisted instruction. My son is currently completing his MM degree in digital music, and is also a career music educator. we KNOW what is out ther, and just how far it can take a student. Having notation software than can divide a beat into 4096 parts is nice - but being able to play a gorgeous melodic phrase, and have flawless technique and exquisite taste - THAT does not come out of a box of circuitry. If it did, those of us who work in this area would have cash in and cashed OUT by now. Art is made by HUMAN BEINGS - although machines can make some part of craft.
A look at what is currently available on eBay
Items recently purchased from this site
Tektronix DSA70404 Real-Time Digital Phosphor Oscilloscope, Tektronix TDS684C Digital Real-Time Oscilloscope, Tektronix TDS694C Digital Real Time Oscilloscope 3GHz 10GS/s OPTIONS 13 1F 2F, Tektronix TDS2014 Digital Real-Time Oscilloscope , Sony Tektronix TDS380P Digital Real-time Oscilloscope, VIDEON DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES E24008RTS 8 CH EMBEDDED Real Time DVR, SAMSUNG 16Channel Real Time Digital Recorder SRD-1650D, Newest Release! 16 Channel DVR w 1TB Hard Drive H.264 Real Time Digital Video, Tektronix - TEK - TDS224 Digital Real-Time Oscilloscope LOADED, J0E- SAMSUNG SRD-852D 8 CHANNEL REAL TIME H.264 200FPS DIGITAL RECORDER 1TB HDD, Tektronix Digital Real-TIme Oscilloscope PN TDS 224 4-Channel/100 mhz, Newest Release! 8 Channel DVR w 1TB Hard Drive H.264 Real Time Digital Video, Tektronix TDS220 2 Ch. Digital Real Time Oscilloscope, TEKTRONIX TDS360 DIGITAL REAL-TIME OSCILLOSCOPE!TDS 360, Tektronix TDS 220 Two Ch Digital Real Time Oscilloscope, Tektronics TDS 220 Digital Real-Time Oscilloscope, Tektronix TDS220 100MHz 2 Channel Digital Real-Time Portable Oscilloscope TESTED, Tektronix TDS 220 TWO CHANNEL DIGITAL REAL-TIME OSCILLOSCOPE 100MHz 1GS/s, TEK TDS 210 TWO CHANNEL DIGITAL REAL-TIME OSCILLOSCOPE , OpenEye! 4 Channel EasyDVR w 500GB Hard Drive H.264 Real Time Digital Video New!, TEKTRONIX TDS360 2 CHAN DIGITAL REAL TIME OSCILLOSCOPE, BOSCH DVR-480-08A050 8CHANNEL CIF REAL TIME DIGITAL RECORDER, Tektronix TDS 210 2-Channel Digital Real Time Oscilliscope - USED, DAGE / MTI DSP 200 DSP200 104662-02 DIGITAL VIDEO REAL-TIME IMAGE PROCESSOR, Tektronix TDS360 Digital Real Time Oscilloscope 2 ch, 1 GS/s, 200 MHz bandwidth, Tektronix TDS210 2-channel digital real time scope 60mhz, Tektronix TDS210 Two channel Digital Real Time Oscilloscope 60MHz 1GS/s 2 probes, Tektronix TDS 210 Two Channel Digital Real Time Oscilloscope 60 MHz 1 GS/s, TRIPP LITE PDUMNV30HV DIGITAL PDU VERTICAL 208/240V 30A W/ REAL TIME REMOTE MO.., Digital Peripheral Solutions Qsdt8pcrp 8ch H.264 Dvr Pci Card W/real-time, Tektronix TDS-360 Digital Real-Time Oscilloscope 200-MHz 2-Channel, National Instruments PXI-7030-6533 Real Time Digital I/O, 3.5" Satlink WS-6912 DVB-S2 Digital Satellite Meter&Real Time Spectrum Analyzer, TEKTRONIX TEKSCOPE THS720 100MHz SCOPE DMM DIGITAL REAL TIME 500MSs OSCILLOSCOPE, Dage MTI DSP2000 High-Resolution Real-Time Digital Image Processor, Qsee Qsdr44drtc-320 4 Real-time Channel Network Digital Video Recorder, 3.5" Satlink WS-6912 DVB-S2 Digital Satellite Meter&Real Time Spectrum Analyzer , SATLINK WS6912 DVB-S2 Digital Satellite Meter & Real Time Spectrum Analyzer, SATLINK WS6912 DVB-S2 Digital Satellite Meter & Real Time Spectrum Analyzer, Tektronix TDS 340A Digital Real-Time Oscilloscope USED , High-Level Synthesis for Real-Time Digital Signal Proce, TRIPP LITE PDUMNV15 DIGITAL PDU 120V 15A VERTICAL W/ REAL TIME REMOTE MONITORING, SATLINK WS6912 DVB-S2 Digital Satellite Finder Meter&Real Time Spectrum Analyzer, RT-EVP Real Time EVP Player Digital Voice Recorder Box GHOST HUNTING Paranormal, H.264 16CH Channel Security Digital Network Real-time DVR System, Digital Peripheral Solutions Qsdt42dpcrc Q-see 4ch Real-time Pci Dvr Card H.264, 8CH Raysharp H.264 Real-Time Network Security CCTV Digital Video Recorder, Olympia Info Globe Digital Caller Id With Real Time Clock Blue Floating LED Spin, Clover QC1100 compact size digital real time quad splitter-Clam Shell Packaged, 16CH channel H.264 Surveillance Real-time network digital DVR System 3G Mobile, Clover QB900 Compact Size, Real Time Digital Quad Split, Compact Size, Real Time Digital Quad Splitter, Color, Cop-USA 15-MP41-1 16-Ch Duplex Multiplexer Real Time Digital Color VCR Input, iCU 4 Channel Real Time CCTV Digital Video Recorder DVR C2A2 Ch, SAMSUNG REAL TIME DIGITAL QUAD SPLITTER SAQ-205, New 8 channel H.264 Surveillance Real-time network cctv digital DVR 3G Mobile, 2.4 GHz Real-time Digital Wireless Baby Monitor IR Night Vision 2-Way Talk, 2.4 GHz Real-time Digital Wireless Baby Monitor IR Night Vision 2-Way Talk, 16 channel digital multiplexer with real time display NEW, Real-Time Digital Signal Processing: From MATLAB to C w, Digital Peripheral Solutions Qsdt4pcrc Q-see 4ch Real-time Pcie Dvr Card H.264, 8 CH Channel H.264 Video CCTV Surveillance Security Digital DVR System Real-time, NEW Digital Inspection Camera w/ Real-Time Video, NIB OLYMPIA Info Globe Digital Caller ID Scrolling LED Real Time Clock, Real-time Digital Signal Processing from MATLAto C with the TMS320C6x DSPs Book, H.264 4CH LAN Real-time network Stand alone Digital DVR Hard Driver Recorder, Digital 8CH Real Time DVR Video Camera Security Card, 8CH 8 Channel H.264 CCTV Real Time DVR Network Mobile Digital Video Recorder, Hands Free Digital Cam w/Small LCD Real Time Display, New Digital Camcorder for Car - Small LCD - Real Time, H.264 8CH Digital Video Recorder DVR Surveillance Security Video Real-Time New, NEW Real-Time Digital Signal Processing from MATLAB to , 4 Channel H.264 Security Digital Video Recorder Network DVR system Real-time , REAL-TIME DIGITAL S - CAMERON H. G. WRIGHT, ET AL. THAD B. WELCH (HARDCOVER) NEW, Real-Time Digital Signal Processing from MATLAB to C with the TMS320C6x DSK, USB-Based CCTV Camera Switch Quad Digital Video Recorder Real Time Frame Capture, 16 CH Digital Video Recorder Capture PCI Card 120 fps Real Time CCTV DVR card, Real-time Digital Signal Processing By Kehtarnavaz, Nasser, REAL-TIME DIGITAL SIGNAL PROCESSING - NASSER KEHTARNAVAZ (PAPERBACK) NEW, Olympia InfoGlobe Digital Caller ID PLUS + Cordless Phone Real-Time Clock OL3020, New 4 CHANNEL DVR CARD 120 FPS CCTV 16 CH Digital VIDEO RECORDER 4 Real time, Digital Real Time Analog/ Digital I/O LSI-11 Manual, Fieldpiece PRH2 Pocket Digital Psychrometer Real-Time, Instant Readings NEW,
